Blue-Eyed Butcher

Sara Paxton

Susan Wright

Justin Bruening

Jeff Wright

W. Earl Brown

Thomas Dean

Michael Gross

Ron Wright

Lucinda Jenney

Susan's Mother

Annie Corley

Mrs. Wright

David Marciano

Detective

Matthew Del Negro

Jeff's Co-Worker

Erin Cahill

Cindy

Annie Wersching

Allie

Lisa Edelstein

Kelly Siegler

Jon Curry

Ben Furhman

Sam McMurray

Dr. Sheffield

Vyto Ruginis

Philip Gross

Pat Skipper

Judge

Aaron Lustig

Dr. Slovin

Cade Owens

Andrew

Jonathan Patrick Moore

Billy

Joshua Snyder

Randy

Zuleyka Silver

Maria

Katrina Norman

Claire

Sashi Bommakanty

Coroner

Angela Arimento

Rosemarie

Nicole Hayden

Neighborhood Mom

Stewart Skelton

Minister

Elijah Adams

Yard Sale Buyer

McKinley Freeman

Constable

Han Nah Kim

Clerk

Andres Perez-Molina

Police Officer

Liz Jenkins

Bank Teller

Rick Chambers

Reporter #2

Deborah Carson

Reporter #3

Anne Marie Howard

Legal Expert

Kirk Hawkins

Pundit

Nancy Grace

Self (uncredited)

Kristian Francis Falkenstein

Groomsman (uncredited)