Return to Sender

Rosamund Pike

Miranda Wells

Shiloh Fernandez

William Finn

Nick Nolte

Mitchell Wells

Rumer Willis

Darlene

Keir O'Donnell

Tony Desantos

Scout Taylor-Compton

Crystal

Illeana Douglas

Judy

Camryn Manheim

Nancy

Alexi Wasser

April

Stephen Louis Grush

Randy

Donna DuPlantier

Karen

Billy Slaughter

Kevin

Ian Barford

Gary Harland

Jeff Pope

Sweet Guard

Ryan Phillippe

UPS Delivery Guy

Liann Pattison

Edith Brown

Tony Bentley

Creepy Customer

Marco St. John

Older Man

Ian Casselberry

Line Cook

Tyler Forrest

Flower Delivery Guy

Lucas Boffin

Josh

Cherrae L. Stuart

Nurse

John McConnell

Choking Man

Samantha Beaulieu

Female Doctor

Janet Lynn Carey

Prison Wife (uncredited)

Estefania Crespo

Sun Bathing Teen (uncredited)

Jesse Yarborough

Restaurant Patron (uncredited)