Closet Monster

Connor Jessup

Oscar Madly (18)

Aaron Abrams

Peter Madly

Joanne Kelly

Brin Madly

Aliocha Schneider

Wilder

Sofia Banzhaf

Gemma

Jack Fulton

Oscar Madly (9)

Mary Walsh

Allison

Isabella Rossellini

Buffy (voice)

Jinji Dawson

Anna

Meghan Cullen

Kathryn

Brad Nippard

Teenage Boy

Megan Kennedy

News Reporter

Sean Panting

Constable Bennett

Megan Rose Jones

Ms. Mercer

Tim Myles

Student

Wangeci Warui

Hardware Store Customer

Jonathan Watton

Larry

Emma McIsaac

Mercedes

Teigan Follett

Greg

Paula Morgan

Christine

Ross Moore

Newlywed Man

Kimberley Drake

Newlywed Woman

James Hawksley

Andrew

Marthe Bernard

Bridgette

Renee Dumaresque

Bridgette's Friend

Leah McPherson

Additional Voices (voice)