I Am Not a Serial Killer

Max Records

John Wayne Cleaver

Christopher Lloyd

Mr. Crowley

Laura Fraser

April Cleaver

Christina Baldwin

Aunt Margaret

Karl Geary

Dr. Neblin

Dee Noah

Kay Crowley

Lucy Lawton

Brooke Watson

Anna Sundberg

Lauren Bacall Cleaver

Raymond Brandstrom

Max

Michael Paul Levin

Max's Dad

Vincent Risso

Rob Anders

Tony Papenfuss

Ron the Coroner

Matt Roy

Drifter

James Gaulke

Principal Layton

Tim Russell

Greg Olsen the Barber

Bruce Bohne

Minister

Dane Stauffer

Mark Watson

Tommy O'Brien

Ethan Watson

Jennifer Blagen

Peg Watson

Jennifer Brandstrom

Max's Mum

Troy Ugrich

Young Police Officer

Butch Eggen

Old Police Officer

A.R. Björklund

Pawnshop Clerk

Elizabeth Belfiori

Rachel

Mary Kay Schmitt

Mrs. Anderson

William Todd-Jones

Jeb Jolley / The Monster

Joshua Carson

Ted Rask the Reporter

Ben Curry

Dave Bird