Tragedy Girls

Brianna Hildebrand

Sadie Cunningham

Alexandra Shipp

McKayla Hooper

Jack Quaid

Jordan Welch

Kevin Durand

Lowell Lehmann

Timothy V. Murphy

Sheriff Blane Welch

Katie Stottlemire

Bookish Student

Nicky Whelan

Mrs. Kent

Elise Neal

Mrs. Hooper

Craig Robinson

Big Al

Andy Bethea

Mr. Hooper

Keith Hudson

Chuck Cunningham

Savannah Jayde

Syl Stanton

Austin Abrams

Craig Thompson

William Tokarsky

Mr. Gordon

Marycarmen Lopez

Trish

Loren Lester

Principal Reid

Rosalind Chao

Mayor Campbell

Kerry Rhodes

Drew

Jenna Day

Fangirl #1

Sophia Mitchell

Fangirl #2

Lee Cruse

Reporter #1

Tara Wescott

Reporter #2

Gene Michael Smith

Driver

Cameron Van Hoy

Deputy

Josh Hutcherson

Toby Mitchell (uncredited)

Jerry Peek

Person on street (uncredited)