When We First Met

Adam Devine

Noah Ashby

Alexandra Daddario

Avery Martin

Shelley Hennig

Carrie Grey

Andrew Bachelor

Max

Robbie Amell

Ethan

Dean J. West

Phil

Tony Cavalero

Angus Young

Delfeayo Marsalis

Danny

Daryn Kahn

Drunk Hulk

Peter Jaymes Jr.

Chad

Martin Bats Bradford

Devon

Noureen DeWulf

Margo

Chelsea Bruland

Mary

Adam Henslee

Amos

Tenea Intriago

Rebecca

Kyler Porche

Trevor

Bertha Bindewald

Marta

Talbott Lin

Mr. Chun

Audrey Bishop

Mrs. Martin

Bill Rainey

Mr. Martin

Bryan Michael Hall

Barista (uncredited)

Chris Wylde

Mr. Costigan

Michael Scott

Garçonne