The Craigslist Killer

Jake McDorman

Phillip Markoff

Agnes Bruckner

Megan McAllister

Julia Campbell

Susan McAllister

Kevin Kilner

David McAllister

Candice Patton

Kate

Judith Hoag

Patricia Banks

Sam McMurray

Dr. Janeway

Joshua Close

Detective Frye

Leela Savasta

Julissa Brisman

Trieste Kelly Dunn

Trisha Leffler

William Baldwin

Detective Bennett

Kerry Knuppe

Janet

Toby Meuli

Tom Wilson

Suzanne Quast

Amber

Alan Wells

Michael McAllister

Jhemma Ziegler

Monica

David Gautreaux

Police Profiler

Greg Vrotsos

Burly Guy

Sandra Sanchez

Newscaster

Robert Dickman

Gun Shop Owner

Healy Lange

Sick Boy's Mother

Sean Persaud

Cell Phone Sales Clerk

Alfonso Freeman

Prison Guard

Kenneth Sears

Prison Guard

Abhi Sinha

Student on TV

Alyce Heath

McAllister Housekeeper

Meredith Vieira

Herself

Anderson Cooper

Himself

Thomas Kasp

Emma's Date

Terri Hoyos

Sophie Flores