Cicada

Matthew Fifer

Ben

Sheldon D. Brown

Sam

Sandra Bauleo

Debbie

Jazmin Grace Grimaldi

Amber

Cobie Smulders

Sophie

Scott Adsit

Dr. Dragone

Michael Potts

Francis

David Burtka

Bo

Jo Firestone

Tracy

Jason Greene

Theresa

Beau Curran

Young Ben

Bowen Yang

Hudson

Clara McGregor

Riley

Kevin William Reed

Mike

Ahmad Maksoud

Mahmoud

Rain Dove Dubilewski

Josh

Tucker Des Lauriers

Justin

Jace Moody

Ray

Kian Talan

Keith

Alexandra Curran

Shay

Rad Hourdakis

Subway Guy

Taka Kita

Smoker

Gil Rodriguez

Gene

Jessica Smith

Steph

Jillian Avery

Chelsea

John Onieal

Sebastian

Ian Mellencamp

Jackson

Ayo Edebiri

Nikki

Michelle Conti

Sarah

Tanner Cohen

Seth (uncredited)

Ashley Haas

Jess (uncredited)

Anthony Oberbeck

Josh (uncredited)

Sarah Pribis

Jordan (uncredited)

Matt Rogers

Phillip (uncredited)

Simone Wasserman

Jill (uncredited)

Jude Dry

Charlie