Cassadaga

Kelen Coleman

Lily

Kevin Alejandro

Mike

Louise Fletcher

Claire

Rus Blackwell

Christian

Lucas Beck

Thomas

Lucius Baston

Officer Hall

Amy LoCicero

Jennifer

Sarah Sculco

Michele

Rachel Durose

Haley

Avis-Marie Barnes

Susan

Hank Stone

Maxwell

Christina Bach

Gabriella

Carlos Navarro

Todd

Amy Dionne Bevly

Cherise

Janine Klein

Mother

Garrett Boyle

Boy

Beth Marshall

Amity / Corrie

Dennis Neal

Det. Hubbard

Randy Molnar

Prof. Randall

Dawn Davis

Teacher

Tracy Wiu

Reporter

J. LaRose

Heath

Amelia Bryant

Classroom Girl #1

Skyler Poiley

Classroom Girl #2

Mark Silverberg

Bus Driver

Hannah DeVane

Onlooker #1

Julio Astacio

Pallbearer

Mark Chandler

Pallbearer

Christine LaRose

Interpreter

Lucas Mullen

Mangled Boy

Brooke Lawless

Nude Model

Garrett Harrison

Baseball Pitcher

Tom Lehm

Outfielder

Nickolas Wolf

4th Grader (uncredited)